Wednesday, August 17, 2022
  • Login
Independent School Management Plus
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Independent School Management Plus
No Result
View All Result
Home Heads & Governors

Is educational populism blinkering leaders’ vision?

The 'rough and tumble' of political populism is seeping into education, with school leaders in danger of being cast in the role of the 'them', writes Peter Hogan

Peter Hogan by Peter Hogan
January 22, 2021
in Heads & Governors
Reading Time: 4 mins read
7 0
A A
0
Is educational populism blinkering leaders’ vision?
Linked InShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin This

There is currently much dissatisfaction with political and other kinds of leadership. There is a backlash against authority and a lot of anger rooted in the same thing – a lack of control.

Our voices are heard, but only where it doesn’t really matter (apologies to all Strictly fans), not where it does. Reactions to Covid, Brexit and the US elections all prove this point.

Trusted sources across the world cite people lacking a sense of purpose and identity, missing out on solidarity and social belonging. We have never been so connected but still feel left out and irrelevant. We can type our opinions and comments everywhere but is anyone reading, caring or doing anything about it? Are we just yelling ourselves hoarse into the void?

These feelings, no matter their source, offer an open goal to the ambitious populist. Whoever can harness the eroding confidence in leaders and stoke the fury at global elites can capture the hearts and minds of many, whatever their previous political persuasion.

It’s all about creating an “us” marshalled into believing they can defeat a “them”. Such populism is nothing new and by the 1950s academics and journalists were applying the word to describe fascist, communist and anti-communist all at the same time. Whatever the ideology of the leaders, it is political catnip for manipulating the masses, helping the self-describing virtuous sweep aside the institutions, groups and people they don’t like as they smash their way into power.

“Should school strategy be all about playing to the gallery?”

We have witnessed parts of the economy, some democratic institutions and the free press getting mangled like this at the hands of populist movements. But despite the fact they all seem to burn out, an ember remains once the movement has gone. There is the idea that all leaders are open to criticism and even abuse as they are the elite no matter who or what they lead. The rough and tumble of political populism is seeping into other parts of life, including education, with school leaders in danger of being cast in the role of the “them”.

When I became a headteacher it was after I had been a teacher and middle manager. I was not fashioned in the lab as an oven-ready head, I was not parachuted in from another sector or another country or hired because my daddy owned the school. I was a left-of-centre, somewhat anti-authoritarian, democratically minded ordinary teacher but as a head I was instantly cast in the role of the “them” and part of the elite by some staff. This is fair enough in many ways and having staff mumping and moaning about the boss goes with the job. But we mustn’t underestimate what is happening here.

As leaders we have a duty to all stakeholders but is our performance some function of their latest opinion and should school strategy be all about playing to the gallery? From Gavin Williamson stating UK education should “overtake Germany” to Labour’s Angela Rayner and the #AbolishEton campaign, the right and left are eager to pull education into their populist “them and us” agendas.

“Leaders are criticised for their failure to serve the needs of whoever has primacy in the populist arena.”

In mainstream and social media there are abundant stories, articles and complaints about how the them in leadership should be doing more to serving the needs of the “us”. Yet there seems to be less about the future needs of children, about vision, about new ideas and the value of learning. The British Education Research Journal in July 2020 identified social media in schools creating division and indifference, setting one group against another and using the language of populism to give voice to the ordinary teacher against a liberal educational elite of academics, local education authorities and teaching unions. Leaders, it seems, are criticised not for their ability to lead but by their failure to serve the needs of whoever has primacy in the populist arena.

I can feel some readers already sharpening their figurative pencils and heading for the comments section to write me off as a bigoted, establishment autocrat but just bear with me a few minutes longer. To react this way is to stumble into the populist log flume, carried along by the belief that what sounds challenging is wrong. Instead I am posing a question about how we cope in this climate of division and deal, as Asimov observed, with the false notion that democracy means that my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge. Do we pull together with shared goals or become more divided and in continual, toxic judgement of each other?

“Staff, parents and children should be more involved in decisions.”

Evidence from the wider world is that populism is neutralised when control is shared, giving people a substantial voice and sense of agency over their lives. Staff, parents and even children should be more involved in strategy—in the fray not on the touchline — with knowledge and devolved power accompanied by accountability and fair representation. Populism will be with us always but if schools are to lead boldly and nurture a better next generation then they need the vision, the will and the freedom to challenge and bring about important change.

In western society, typically driven by neoliberal values and economic interests rather than true equality and consensus, schools are uniquely placed to strengthen democratic institutions. Schools can show children how their beliefs are shaped by others, how their emotions are manipulatied by networking sites and how the bubble filters they occupy reinforce political polarization.

We can teach children about social problems, the value of tolerance and social justice and the importance of questioning of an existing socio-economic order where so many do not feel empowered to participate in democracy and improve social structures. Schools can deliver the antidote to authoritarian populism, but we cannot do this while cowed.

Don't miss out!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Receive top education news, lesson ideas, teaching tips and more!
Invalid email address
Give it a try. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
Tags: independent schoolspoliticspopulismschools
Share2Share9Tweet6Pin2
Peter Hogan

Peter Hogan

Video

  • All
  • Video
In Conversation: Will Goldsmith, headteacher, Bedales School
Alumni Relations

In Conversation: Louise Bennett, chief executive, IDPE

July 8, 2022
102
The Friday Club: Ranald Lloyd-Williams, Feel Good Films
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Ranald Lloyd-Williams, Feel Good Films

July 5, 2022
86
Back pain Clare Rawlings from Raw Movement
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Clare Rawlings, movement expert

July 3, 2022
100
The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School

June 20, 2022
86

Latest News

Don't ban the Confucius Institutes, says Thomas Camilleri
Heads & Governors

‘Banning Confucius Institutes would only hold Britain back’

July 25, 2022
310
Ashbrooke House School announces closure
Bursars & Finance

Independent Ashbrooke House School announces closure

July 18, 2022
297
mindfulness might not improve teenagers' mental health
Latest News

Mindfulness training has ‘no impact’ on secondary pupil wellbeing

July 13, 2022
225
Julie Robinson from the Independent Schools Council reflects on the year
Admissions & Marketing

Labour’s independent schools plans ‘a tax on aspiration’

July 12, 2022
182
Andrea Jenkyns, minister DFE
Heads & Governors

Chartered College complains over minister’s middle finger gesture

July 11, 2022
97
James Cleverley Education secretary
Latest News

Michelle Donelan resigns, replaced by James Cleverly

July 7, 2022
170
Independent School Management Plus

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
  • Educators
  • Your School
  • Jobs
  • Video & Podcast
  • Resources
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.