Thursday, June 30, 2022
  • Login
Independent School Management Plus
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Independent School Management Plus
No Result
View All Result
Home College Counselling

‘Patronising, self-serving institutional posturing’

As the application deadline for Oxbridge looms next week, Peter Green responds to a recent call for privately educated students to apply elsewhere

Peter Green by Peter Green
October 8, 2021
in College Counselling, Exams & Qualifications, Heads & Governors
Reading Time: 3 mins read
259 11
A A
0
Peter Green Rugby school, Oxbridge
Linked InShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin This

The suggestion by Dorothy Byrne, the new head of Cambridge’s Murray Edwards College, that Etonians would be better off going to northern universities to meet “more diverse people” is ill-considered and flabby. Much like the reason she allegedly thought she was suitable for the job at the women-only college — because she thought that largely white men in positions of power had messed up the country during the pandemic.

It is hard to believe that the interview panel pressed her to expand on either of these statements. Has she heard of Kate Bingham, Sarah Gilbert and Catherine Green?

Her call for Cambridge to take 93 per cent of its students from state schools for its intake to be representative of society misses the point of going to university. Certainly, Murray Edwards College cannot be representative of society if it excludes men.

“We all know that house prices are inflated in those areas where there are good state schools.”

Ms Byrne also ignores the fact that maintained schools are not identical; they include grammar schools and those in wealthy areas, for example. We all know that house prices are inflated in those areas where there are good state schools. And not all independent schools are like Eton — far from it. Ms Byrne may also be interested to know that many of them are located in the north, some of them near to where she went to university herself.

Universities should accept the best candidates, who are bright, curious, open-minded and ambitious, who love their chosen subjects and will work hard, seize the opportunities on offer, and demonstrate potential. Of course, universities should seek to widen access but they should not be chasing quotas.

Independent school students are not obsessed, as Ms Byrne claims, with getting into Oxford and Cambridge. Increasingly, students are choosing a course rather than a university and look at a wide range of universities to find the ones that might suit them best, for all sorts of reasons.  A significant number of our students go to Manchester, Sheffield, Newcastle — and even further north to Edinburgh, Glasgow and St Andrews.

“Universities should seek to widen access but they should not be chasing quotas.”

To discriminate against candidates from independent schools is unfair and prejudicial. All students should have an equal chance of admission.

Not all of Rugby School students come from rich backgrounds (and even if they did, banning them  from applying to Cambridge would be discrimination against the children because of the parents). Many of them have families who make great sacrifices for them to attend Rugby because their local schools are unable to provide the kind of tuition that would prepare them adequately for entrance to a top university (wherever it is located).

41 per cent of our students have assistance with their fees and nearly 30 students every year have 100 per cent of their boarding fees — plus extras — paid by our Arnold Foundation bursary programme. Most independent schools have similar programmes. Most of us also have partnership arrangements with local state schools to give access to drama and music, and to teach higher maths, classics and modern foreign languages, for example, to a level that many state schools are unable to provide.

“Rugby is certainly not a school that is full of ‘people like us'”

These partnerships extend to invitations to attend sessions for our 6th form students on understanding the Oxbridge admissions processes and how to apply. These include subject enrichment sessions and mock Oxbridge interviews and, until recently, an admissions tutor from a Cambridge or Oxford college would attend. They are now reluctant to support this initiative in fear of being seen to have a special relationship with an independent school, despite the mix of students in the room.

Meanwhile, Cambridge University charges fees from its students whatever their backgrounds, disadvantaged or not. I would suggest that this is an area more worthy of reform than arbitrating on the socio-economic backgrounds of its intake.

Rugby is certainly not a school that is full of “people like us” so we do not need to be told by Ms Byrne that by “going north” our students have the advantage of meeting people “who are not like them”. In fact, I think that our students would regard this, as I do, as not only out-dated and patronising, but self-serving institutional posturing.

Don't miss out!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Receive top education news, lesson ideas, teaching tips and more!
Invalid email address
Give it a try. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
Tags: cambridgeheroindependent schoolsOxbridge applicationsoxford
Share59Share340Tweet212Pin76
Peter Green

Peter Green

Peter Green is executive headmaster, Rugby School Group.

Video

  • All
  • Video
The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School

June 20, 2022
67
Richard Backhouse is chair of the HMC and sits down with Helen Wright
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Richard Backhouse, Chair, HMC

June 14, 2022
236
Podcast: Hannah Rankin – Boxing clever
Nicholas McKie

Podcast: Hannah Rankin – Boxing clever

June 14, 2022
126
Delyth Lynch, deputy head, safeguarding, Wellington College
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Delyth Lynch, deputy head, safeguarding, Wellington College

June 14, 2022
259

Latest News

Cricket over at Lord's for Eton and Harrow
Latest News

National schools’ contest to replace Eton and Harrow Lord’s match

June 29, 2022
42
Haberdashers' Monmouth Schools
Admissions & Marketing

Haberdashers’ Monmouth Schools consult over co-ed plans

June 28, 2022
149
teacher recruitment: rise in job adverts
Heads & Governors

Report reveals concerns over school staff shortages

June 20, 2022
162
TES Schools Awards
Admissions & Marketing

Independent schools celebrate at TES Schools Awards

June 18, 2022
241
to many exams
Assessment

Too much emphasis on exams, say parents

June 17, 2022
90
Year 6 entering secondary
Latest News

Study reveals teachers’ concerns for secondary transition

June 14, 2022
84
Independent School Management Plus

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
  • Educators
  • Your School
  • Jobs
  • Video & Podcast
  • Resources
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.