Thursday, June 30, 2022
  • Login
Independent School Management Plus
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Independent School Management Plus
No Result
View All Result
Home College Counselling

Oxbridge: ‘Don’t crudely define applicants by their school or postcode’

Bernard Trafford fears that 'simplistic measures and targets' for Oxbridge admissions are here to stay

Bernard Trafford by Bernard Trafford
May 18, 2022
in College Counselling, Heads & Governors
Reading Time: 3 mins read
10 0
A A
0
Oxbridge should move award from crude targets, writes Bernard Trafford
Linked InShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin This

What a furore. “Oxbridge to exclude private school pupils” shrieked the banner headlines, following an announcement by Professor Stephen Toope, Cambridge’s vice-chancellor.

Expressions of outrage followed from the supporters of both the independent sector and of grammar schools, which were also targeted.

Trouble is, none of this is quite what it seems. Professor Toope didn’t actually propose creating barriers for privately educated pupils: the headline-writers did. He was outlining the top universities’ efforts to prioritise offers of places to applicants from disadvantaged backgrounds, and acknowledging the potential fallout.

Oxbridge is responding to significant government pressure: but there’s a moral imperative too. Selective schools, state and independent, do much the same. Government’s leaning on them, too: but it’s also the right thing to do, as they rediscover the charitable origins that might have been lost sight of.

“The threat to that minority of schools – and their aspirant pupils – is clear.”

Let’s not be starry-eyed about this, though. The threat to that minority of schools – and their aspirant pupils – is clear. Oxford and Cambridge publish ratios of their state to privately/selectively schooled entrants, and need to ensure that the first figure rises annually. Easy to see how hard-pressed admissions teams might be tempted to sort applications as “state comprehensive – good” and “independent/grammar – bad”.

Barnaby Lenon, chair of the Independent Schools Council, rightly warns that taking an applicant’s private schooling as a proxy for privilege is misleading. Simplistic targets and statistics always carry a risk, particularly when attempting to measure a grey area.

It certainly is grey. Let’s start with pupils from poorer homes who attend independent schools funded by bursaries. That number, arguably a small proportion, is growing all the time. The more successfully private schools work on their outreach, the more they take risks on candidates: will the education they provide to a child who shows promise sufficiently compensate for aspects of their disadvantage? Often it will: yet university drop-out rates demonstrate how often difficulties presented by home circumstances are insuperable.

“The level of academic selection in the independent sector is generally overstated.”

Nor are all those who pay school fees wealthy. The range of private school fees is enormously wide. Families help, and sometimes parents incur huge debt to get what they see as the best for their child.

Then there’s the matter of academic selection. Within the independent sector, its level is generally overstated: to see really ferocious selection, look at the highest-scoring state grammars where ten, twenty or more children apply for every place. Those same grammar schools are frequently criticised for taking few pupils from disadvantage backgrounds.

But some schools blur even that line. London now boasts some super-selective state sixth forms: Harris Westminster, London School of Excellence and Brampton Manor Academy, Newham routinely win more Oxbridge places than Eton (the first two are sponsored by various powerful independent schools: Eton plans to extend the model into the North).

“Many bright, highly-motivated and well-supported children do attend comprehensives.”

The mainly disadvantaged pupils who currently populate these colleges nonetheless benefit from the double blessings of formidable ability-levels and hugely supportive, if impecunious, families. Is that perhaps a form of privilege? And how long before what David Cameron dubbed the “sharp-elbowed middle-classes” move into those settings, just as they colonise “desirable” comprehensives’ catchments areas, inflating house prices?

Many bright, highly-motivated and well-supported children do attend comprehensives. The Times featured one who went to Cambridge from an “ordinary” school – but enjoyed what she herself described as the privilege of being born to two university academics.

I neither praise nor criticise the schools, pupils or families I’ve characterised above, simply seeking to demonstrate how any debate on privilege versus disadvantage is far more complex than the screaming newspaper headlines suggest, and demands more intelligent consideration.

“Government should buy places for disadvantaged pupils at private schools: not to prop them up but to crack them open.”

All candidates for Oxbridge, and for Higher Education more widely, should be considered as individuals, rather than being crudely defined by their school or postcode. Government and universities should find the courage to adopt PQA (a procedure whereby candidates would apply for university places after receiving their exam results), thus eliminating the labyrinth of conditional offers. At that point, the selection system should be sufficiently sophisticated and humane to take account of the background to applicants’ results.

Moreover, government should buy places for disadvantaged pupils at private schools: not to prop them up but, conversely, to crack them open.

Don’t say it can’t be done: it can. The pandemic showed Government can do as/when it chooses. But I fear it will stick to simplistic measures and targets, creating bogus statistics that it can present as success.

And, overall, pupils will lose out.

Don't miss out!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Receive top education news, lesson ideas, teaching tips and more!
Invalid email address
Give it a try. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
Tags: Oxbridgeuniversity admissions
Share2Share12Tweet8Pin3
Bernard Trafford

Bernard Trafford

Dr Bernard Trafford, now a writer and published composer, was head of two major independent schools between 1990 and 2017 and 2007-9 chair of the HMC. In 2018 he served briefly as interim principal of The Purcell School where he is now chair of governors.

Video

  • All
  • Video
The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School

June 20, 2022
67
Richard Backhouse is chair of the HMC and sits down with Helen Wright
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Richard Backhouse, Chair, HMC

June 14, 2022
236
Podcast: Hannah Rankin – Boxing clever
Nicholas McKie

Podcast: Hannah Rankin – Boxing clever

June 14, 2022
126
Delyth Lynch, deputy head, safeguarding, Wellington College
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Delyth Lynch, deputy head, safeguarding, Wellington College

June 14, 2022
259

Latest News

Cricket over at Lord's for Eton and Harrow
Latest News

National schools’ contest to replace Eton and Harrow Lord’s match

June 29, 2022
42
Haberdashers' Monmouth Schools
Admissions & Marketing

Haberdashers’ Monmouth Schools consult over co-ed plans

June 28, 2022
149
teacher recruitment: rise in job adverts
Heads & Governors

Report reveals concerns over school staff shortages

June 20, 2022
162
TES Schools Awards
Admissions & Marketing

Independent schools celebrate at TES Schools Awards

June 18, 2022
241
to many exams
Assessment

Too much emphasis on exams, say parents

June 17, 2022
90
Year 6 entering secondary
Latest News

Study reveals teachers’ concerns for secondary transition

June 14, 2022
84
Independent School Management Plus

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
  • Educators
  • Your School
  • Jobs
  • Video & Podcast
  • Resources
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.