Wednesday, August 17, 2022
  • Login
Independent School Management Plus
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Independent School Management Plus
No Result
View All Result
Home Bursars & Finance

Rates relief cut: ‘It’s personal, political and vindictive’

Cutting rates relief for Scottish independent schools will have the 'perverse' effect of making them less accessible, writes Melvyn Roffe

Melvyn Roffe by Melvyn Roffe
December 20, 2021
in Bursars & Finance, Heads & Governors
Reading Time: 3 mins read
12 0
A A
0
Melvyn roffe us unhappy about Scottish schools losing rates relief
Linked InShare on FacebookShare on TwitterPin This

It looks as if it is finally going to happen. After a stay of execution during the pandemic, independent schools in Scotland will lose their Non-Domestic Rates Relief from April 2022. Unsurprisingly, there has been no howl of protest at this news. If anyone outside the sector were paying attention, they probably nodded quietly in approval at the Scottish Government removing the tax breaks enjoyed by those “posh schools”.

And so, one of the most illogical and unfair fiscal measures enacted in recent times will be implemented. Scottish independent schools are already the only charities in any UK jurisdiction that must prove to the satisfaction of the regulator that they actually provide charitable benefit. They are now also to be the only ones deprived of one of the major benefits of charitable status. They may be forgiven for thinking that it’s something personal.

“If I own a private offshore company routing profits via the Cayman Islands, I can operate nurseries in Scotland and pay no rates.”

But it gets worse. If I own a private offshore company routing profits via the Cayman Islands, I can operate nurseries in Scotland and pay no rates. But if the same nurseries are operated by a Scottish charity that happens to be an independent school, the whole rates bill is payable. It’s not only personal, it is also highly political – and vindictive.

It is also disingenuous and self-defeating, of course. Far from costing the state money in lost tax revenue, anyone who bothers to understand the sector knows that we save the state millions a year. At a conservative calculation, my school alone saves the state about a million pounds every month by educating children and young people who would otherwise be in state schools. Against that, our annual £450,000 of rates relief looks like a pretty good deal for the state.

It is difficult to know what the impact will be on schools. It may be that the Scottish Government is banking on the continued resilience and ingenuity of independent sector and the willingness and ability of parents to pay a little bit more for what they value in their children’s education. Let’s hope they are right in doing so.

“Attacking so-called ‘elitist schools’ by increasing their costs has the perverse effect of making them that little bit less accessible.”

But there is clearly a risk that on top of all the other financial challenges that Covid and Brexit have presented, some schools will not manage to either absorb this additional overhead or pass it on to fee-paying parents without affecting their pupil numbers or long-term financial planning.

And even if they do manage, an impact on bursary funding and affordability is highly likely. We know from previous experience that attacking so-called “elitist schools” by increasing their cost base has the perverse but inevitable effect of simply making them that little bit less accessible.”

“Doom-mongers see this as the thin end of a very nasty wedge.”

And what of the future? Doom-mongers see this as the thin end of a very nasty wedge, the thick end of which is VAT on fees, the end of charitable status and even forms of proscription. More cheery types suggest it might in fact be “red meat” to convince the more ravenous of SNP supporters that the sector has had the kicking they think it deserves, so enabling the Government to take a more pragmatic line in the future.

There is evidence to support that view in some of the First Minister’s words and in the exclusion of policy on independent schools from the recent agreement between the SNP and the Scottish Greens.

Depressingly, none of this is about the great work that schools do for their pupils and their communities. It is too much to ask that one day policy should be driven by an understanding of that?

Don't miss out!
Subscribe To Newsletter
Receive top education news, lesson ideas, teaching tips and more!
Invalid email address
Give it a try. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
Tags: charitable statusindepedent schoolsscotlandtax breaks
Share3Share16Tweet10Pin4
Melvyn Roffe

Melvyn Roffe

Melvyn Roffe is principal at George Watson's College in Edinburgh, Scotland.

Video

  • All
  • Video
In Conversation: Will Goldsmith, headteacher, Bedales School
Alumni Relations

In Conversation: Louise Bennett, chief executive, IDPE

July 8, 2022
102
The Friday Club: Ranald Lloyd-Williams, Feel Good Films
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Ranald Lloyd-Williams, Feel Good Films

July 5, 2022
86
Back pain Clare Rawlings from Raw Movement
Heads & Governors

In Conversation: Clare Rawlings, movement expert

July 3, 2022
100
The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School
Admissions & Marketing

The Friday Club: Rachell Fox, Channing School

June 20, 2022
86

Latest News

Don't ban the Confucius Institutes, says Thomas Camilleri
Heads & Governors

‘Banning Confucius Institutes would only hold Britain back’

July 25, 2022
310
Ashbrooke House School announces closure
Bursars & Finance

Independent Ashbrooke House School announces closure

July 18, 2022
297
mindfulness might not improve teenagers' mental health
Latest News

Mindfulness training has ‘no impact’ on secondary pupil wellbeing

July 13, 2022
225
Julie Robinson from the Independent Schools Council reflects on the year
Admissions & Marketing

Labour’s independent schools plans ‘a tax on aspiration’

July 12, 2022
182
Andrea Jenkyns, minister DFE
Heads & Governors

Chartered College complains over minister’s middle finger gesture

July 11, 2022
97
James Cleverley Education secretary
Latest News

Michelle Donelan resigns, replaced by James Cleverly

July 7, 2022
170
Independent School Management Plus

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
  • Educators
  • Your School
  • Jobs
  • Video & Podcast
  • Resources
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Latest
  • Leaders
    • School Owners & Operators
    • Heads & Governors
    • Alumni Relations
    • Bursars & Finance
    • Admissions & Marketing
    • Development & Fundraising
    • Communications & PR
    • Campus Design & Experience
    • Estate Management
    • Human Resources
    • School data management
    • CPD
  • Educators
    • Safeguarding
    • College Counselling
    • Curriculum Design
    • Online Learning & Innovation
    • Early Years
    • Exams & Qualifications
    • Assessment
    • Inclusion
    • Sports and Outdoors
    • Wellbeing
    • eSports
  • Your School
    • Spotlight on a School
    • 30 minutes with…
    • The View From Here
    • School news and announcements
  • Jobs
    • Vacancies
    • Recruitment
    • Movers & Shakers
  • Video & Podcast
    • Inspiring Leadership
    • School Leaders
    • Membership Bodies
    • The ABC of Safeguarding
    • The Friday Club
  • Resources
    • From Our Partners
    • Supplier Directory
  • About
    • Editorial Board
    • Associations & Distribution
    • Our Publications
      • International School Magazine
      • School Management Plus Magazine
      • Wellbeing in International Schools Magazine
      • WISEducation newsletter
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us

© 2020 Independent School Management Plus.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.